ANECA avanza en el proyecto PEI3AC para ensayar nuevas metodologías de evaluación en el marco de CoARA

ANECA moves forward with the PEI3AC project to test new assessment methodologies within the CoARA framework

  • 20/11/2025

  • CoARA

The National Agency for Quality Assessment and Accreditation (ANECA) was one of the institutions that secured funding in the second call for proposals for CoARA Boost-Cascade Funding, part of the Horizon Europe - WIDERA program, to develop a research project on evaluation methodologies between 2025 and 2026.

This call aims to promote institutional change and support pilot and knowledge-sharing initiatives, funding more than twenty projects that develop new innovative initiatives within their institutions and enable lasting institutional change.

Within this framework, ANECA has launched its pilot project “Pilot Experiments for Innovative Academic Assessment under ANECA's CoARA Action Plan” (PEI3AC), in which 50 evaluators from the ACADEMIA program will participate on a voluntary basis. This initiative, aligned with the objectives of the European call for proposals in which it is framed, seeks to obtain evidence to improve the implementation of qualitative methodologies in assessment and to promote a more responsible and fair assessment that is adapted to the diversity of academic trajectories. In addition, it will serve as a tool to advance the training of evaluators for the implementation of the new assessment model.

This project is expected to improve understanding of evaluation practice, promote responsible evaluation practices, and strengthen alignment with CoARA commitments, as well as monitor the implementation of reforms and understand the factors that influence evaluation, with the aim of guiding future reforms in evaluation systems, both at ANECA and other European agencies and institutions.

The project consists of three experiments:

  • Pilot on narrative CVs: This pilot tests the use of narrative CVs versus traditional CVs. The aim is to understand how each format influences evaluators' decisions and whether the narrative approach allows for a better assessment of staff quality and contributions.
  • Pilot on qualitative evaluation versus quantitative indicators: This pilot explores evaluation models focused on qualitative descriptions of research work, rather than relying solely on citation metrics. The aim is to analyze whether these methods allow for a more comprehensive and fair assessment that is aligned with the actual quality of the research.
  • Pilot on bias mitigation: This pilot tests strategies to reduce unconscious bias in evaluation processes. Its objective is to identify measures that can improve equity and inclusion and assess their real impact on how research trajectories and results are evaluated.