ANECA Working Sessions with the Federation of Finnish Learned Societies in Helsinki

ANECA working sessions with the Federation of Finnish Learned Societies in Helsinki

  • 16/06/2026

On June 16, 17, and 18, ANECA conducted an institutional visit to the Federation of Finnish Learned Societies in Helsinki, in response to an invitation from the latter. Representing ANECA was Irene Ramos Vielba, an advisory member of the Executive Board, and representing the Federation of Finnish Learned Societies were Janne Pölönen and Mira Söderman, along with representatives from various Finnish institutions. The focus of these working sessions was on the FIN-CAM tool for evaluating research staff, with special attention given to its role in promoting responsible evaluation practices.

FIN-CAM is a tool primarily designed to evaluate research staff for research careers, although it can also support research organizations, funding agencies, and other evaluation processes. Its approach encompasses multiple dimensions—including research, teaching, social interaction, and open science—through adaptable criteria. The tool is based on best practices in evaluation, aligned with the National Recommendation on Responsible Evaluation and CoARA’s commitments, as it recognizes the diversity of contributions and career paths. Its development began in 2020; it incorporated a survey of research staff in 2023 and a revision subject to public consultation in 2025, and plans to launch a web-based tool in 2026 to facilitate various uses.

The first day included a meeting with the Finnish Education Evaluation Centre (FINEEC). The discussion focused on FIN-CAM’s connection to institutional quality assurance, particularly with regard to audits of internal quality systems, self-evaluation, and the potential integration of CoARA principles into governance activities. They also discussed its relationship with European standards and guidelines (ESG) in areas such as teaching, learning, and pilot initiatives linked to research, as well as the support provided by CoARA National Chapters and quality assurance agencies.
The second session focused on the FIN-CAM development process, from identifying its analytical dimensions to defining its building blocks, criteria, and examples. Its flexible, inclusive, and non-prescriptive nature was highlighted, as it is designed to adapt to different disciplines, types of research, and institutional contexts. The discussion addressed the balance between conceptual rigor and practical utility, as well as the importance of the participatory process that brought together universities, research organizations, funders, unions, experts, and potential users to build a common tool capable of recognizing the diversity of research contributions and trajectories.

The final working session focused on the transferability and adaptation of FIN-CAM to other institutional and national contexts. Participants discussed which dimensions and principles could remain unchanged and which elements required adjustments, particularly with regard to terminology, examples, strategic priorities, and existing evaluation frameworks. The role of qualitative descriptions and the functionalities needed to document evidence, support evaluators and institutions, and integrate the tool into various processes was also addressed. Finally, the group worked on two potential case studies: a national program for evaluating knowledge transfer and exchange activities, and the evaluation of research activity at a peripheral university, exploring how FIN-CAM could help recognize different contributions in other settings.

The visit opened new avenues for continuing the collaboration initiated between ANECA and the Federation of Finnish Learned Societies, particularly in the exchange of experiences regarding responsible evaluation and the adaptation of tools to different institutional objectives.

As a next step, FIN-CAM is scheduled to be presented this fall in a webinar aimed at institutions in the Spanish National Chapter of CoARA, with the goal of raising awareness of the tool and exploring its usefulness for advancing responsible, inclusive, and context-sensitive evaluation practices.