Meeting of Ibero-American agencies for scientific evaluation and publication in Montevideo

Meeting of Ibero-American agencies for scientific evaluation and publication in Montevideo

  • 05/10/2026

On 21 and 22 September 2026, the Spanish Cooperation Training Centre in Montevideo hosted the event: ‘Promoting science in Spanish and Portuguese: Meeting of Ibero-American agencies for scientific evaluation and publication’, an initiative promoted by the Directorate-General for Spanish in the World (Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the European Union and Cooperation) and the National Agency for Quality Assessment and Accreditation (ANECA), in collaboration with the Spanish Agency for International Development Cooperation (AECID) and the Ibero-American General Secretariat (SEGIB).

The meeting provided a forum for reflection and exchange in the fields of research evaluation, science policy, academic publishing and scientific information infrastructures across thirteen Ibero-American countries. Participants included representatives from evaluation and funding agencies, ministries and bodies responsible for science, technology and innovation, universities and research centres, publishing networks, scientific information platforms and Ibero-American organisations.

The programme took place over two days. The first day, co-organised by ANECA, focused on the challenges involved in moving towards more equitable systems for evaluating academic careers and research activity in Ibero-America, incorporating the perspectives of evaluation agencies, experts and the Coalition for the Advancement of Research Assessment (CoARA). In addition, a workshop addressed the practical application of these principles, with particular attention to the recognition and evaluation of scientific output in Spanish and Portuguese and, more broadly, to the diversity of practices, missions and knowledge ecosystems within the Ibero-American region.

In her address, the director of ANECA, Pilar Paneque, shared her thoughts on strategies and best practices aimed at moving towards evaluation models that are more responsible, equitable and tailored to the diversity of scientific contexts. Drawing on the Agency’s experience, she highlighted the importance of adopting a participatory, coordinated and progressive approach, based on deliberation and consensus-building with the scientific community and the various stakeholders involved. She also emphasised the need to promote processes of continuous improvement that allow adjustments to be made based on experience, as well as to establish coordination mechanisms that bring together existing efforts. He also emphasised the importance of accompanying these processes with accountability and self-assessment systems that enable progress to be assessed, opportunities for improvement to be identified and the effectiveness of evaluation policies to be strengthened.

The second day focused on strengthening Ibero-America’s position in the international scientific arena from a geopolitical perspective, as well as on the practical tools and solutions needed to promote this. The programme was rounded off with a workshop, on this occasion dedicated to ‘diamond’ journals, aimed at helping to define an Ibero-American roadmap to advance the recognition and positioning of Spanish and Portuguese in science.

Among the main conclusions of the meeting, the need to move towards more responsible, qualitative and context-sensitive scientific evaluation systems was highlighted – systems capable of recognising linguistic diversity, as well as diversity in contributions, disciplines and academic careers. Furthermore, the strengthening of Spanish and Portuguese must be compatible with the internationalisation of science, through the promotion of a multilingual environment and greater coherence between evaluation criteria and open science policies.

The importance of harnessing and linking existing scientific capacities and infrastructure in Ibero-America to improve the visibility and recognition of regional scientific output was also highlighted. In this regard, the key challenges identified were overcoming the fragmentation of initiatives, improving data interoperability and quality, and strengthening collaboration between evaluation agencies, platforms, publishers and scientific institutions.

Looking ahead, the meeting helped to identify potential areas of work to consolidate Ibero-American scientific cooperation. These include promoting a shared regional agenda; strengthening collaboration between evaluation agencies and institutions; improving the coordination and interoperability of regional scientific infrastructures and platforms; and developing capacities in responsible evaluation through training and the exchange of experiences and good practices.