2025_working_group_CoARA

CoARA's Academic Career Assessment Working Group analyzes the reform promoted by ANECA

  • 05/05/2025

  • CoARA

The working group 'Academic Career Assessment Reform' is one of the 13 thematic communities of practice currently available to the Coalition for the Advancement of Research Assessment (CoARA) to promote its practical implementation. This group is coordinated by Pastora Martinez, commissioner for international action at the Universitat Oberta de Catalunya and co-chair of the EUA Open Science group, and Moniek Tromp of the Young Academy of Europe.

Since its launch in October 2023 and with 39 members from 21 countries, with a European and global scope, the group seeks to extend the reflection on the evaluation of research to other academic activities (teaching, innovation, management/leadership and service to society) to adequately reflect the different tasks, functions and roles that teaching and research staff perform throughout their careers.

To gain insight into the state of the art of the reforms underway in this area, this group surveyed nearly 200 academic organizations, the vast majority of them European, and analyzed 11 pioneering reform initiatives to improve academic career evaluation. Among them, the reforms implemented by ANECA have been one of those explored as a case study.

From this wealth of data, the group has drawn the following six powerful insights that provide a snapshot of the changing terrain of academic career assessment:

  1. Academic organizations around the world are moving toward reform.
  2. Reform is possible.
  3. Academics are the key to success.
  4. The scope of academic career assessment is expanding.
  5. Bibliometrics tells a story, but not the whole story.
  6. Reform requires an open conversation about the nature of quality and excellence.

The lessons learned clearly show that change is underway, confirming common expectations and also highlighting important challenges yet to be resolved. In this sense and with all the information gathered, the working group is currently working on a “toolbox” that can support those organizations that are committed to move forward in the reform of academic career assessment.

More information: https://coara.eu/working-groups/working-groups/wg-reforming-academic-career-assessment/